I’m not strange; I’m Unstrange

Category: Communication

ASHA and the Fight Over Assisted Spelling for Communication

Close-up of a dark-skinned hand resting on a white computer keyboard with blank, unlabeled keys.

The Latest News in an Ongoing Battle to Be Heard

The American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) holds its convention this November, and four sessions on the program are devoted to warning clinicians away from facilitated communication (FC), the Rapid Prompting Method (RPM), and Spelling to Communicate (S2C).

Session 1066 covers how to administer and interpret authorship testing. Session 1181 aims to debunk the “myth” that apraxia explains why a nonspeaker relies on a communication partner. Session 1367, a Meritorious Session, covers the “top myths” behind these methods. Session 1934 is about “lived experiences of harms.” The same four names present or co-author all four sessions.

This follows ASHA’s August 20, 2026 comments on the federal IACC Strategic Plan, which objected to federal protection for text-based and letter-based communication approaches and restated that the evidence does not support FC, RPM, or similar facilitator-dependent methods. ASHA’s first statement on FC dates to 1995, and its 2018 position statement calls FC a discredited technique.

Much of what follows draws on David Kaufer’s essay “What Is ASHA Afraid Of?” Kaufer’s son, Stone, is a nonspeaking Autistic self-advocate who communicates by spelling, so Kaufer writes from the closest proximity to this question (other than Spellers, themselves, of course.)

What ASHA Says About Assisted Communication

ASHA’s stated position is that these methods lack evidence, that authorship cannot be verified, and that the facilitator may be influencing the message. The position statement also warns that FC could be used to make false accusations of sexual abuse. Those are serious concerns, and they deserve to be stated fairly.

What ASHA recommends instead is the same family of tools used without a facilitator: letter boards, keyboards, pointing to pictures, and speech-generating devices, used independently, with prompts faded. Diane Paul, ASHA’s Senior Director of Clinical Services, said as much in testimony to the Vermont House Human Services Committee on April 9, 2026. So the line ASHA draws is not the letter board itself. It is the communication partner’s hands on the process.

Who is Steering the Push to Have Assisted Communication Declared Harmful?

Kaufer names four researchers: Howard Shane (decades in AAC technology), Bronwyn Hemsley (speech pathologist with clinical experience), Katharine Beals (linguistics PhD, no clinical license), and Russell Lang (board-certified behavior analyst). By Kaufer’s account, none is a neurologist, and none specializes in motor planning or apraxia. They authored the position statements, wrote the journal response to Kaufer, and run the convention track.

Kaufer also points to financial stakes. Shane holds equity in a company selling a communication program he developed, and Beals designs and sells a competing language curriculum. Three of the four have served as paid expert witnesses in litigation on this question, including a 2024 case in which Shane and Beals were defense experts for a school district sued for denying a student access to S2C.

Kaufer makes a strong structural point: Professional associations run on volunteers. The most motivated people write the statements and review the next proposals, and the group ends up citing its own earlier statements. None of that requires bad faith. It is simply how a closed loop forms.

What Kaufer Says About ASHA’s Stance

Kaufer writes, “A genuinely closed question doesn’t require an annual, expanding campaign to keep it closed.” In other words, if it’s so obvious that FC, RPM, S2C, etc. are harmful, why would they have to work this hard on an ongoing basis to discredit those methods of communication? Who is keeping these systems alive and so vibrant that ASHA’s attention to the topic has grown every year?

The counter-evidence he offers is people. Nonspeaking communicators using these methods are living full public lives. Woody Brown graduated from UCLA in 2022, earned an MFA at Columbia in 2024, and wrote the novel Upward Bound. Elizabeth Bonker graduated from Rollins in 2022 with a 4.0 and gave the valedictorian address by text-to-voice. Hari Srinivasan graduated from UC Berkeley with a 4.0 and is a PhD candidate at Vanderbilt studying the neuroscience of autism. Ido Kedar was mainstreamed, graduated fourth in his class, and has published two books. Jordyn Zimmerman keynoted ASHA’s own convention in 2022.

Kaufer’s proposal for accountability has three parts: real disclosure of competing interests at every chokepoint, outside expertise from motor planning and neurology researchers before clinical guidance is issued, and opening the convention stage to the people the debate is about.

What the Research Does and Does Not Show

The claim that no study has ever reported evidence of communicator authorship is not an accurate description of the published literature. Many peer-reviewed studies report evidence that the disabled person originated the communication. These include tests where the facilitator did not know the target information (Cardinal and colleagues, 1996; Sheehan and Matuozzi, 1996; Weiss and colleagues, 1996; Olney, 2001), eye-tracking and movement studies showing anticipatory gaze and active movement initiation (Grayson and colleagues, 2012; Jaswal and colleagues, 2020; Faure and colleagues, 2021), linguistic and stylometric analyses finding user-specific patterns (Niemi and Kärnä-Lin, 2002; Tuzzi, 2009; Nicoli and colleagues, 2023), and reports of later typing without physical support (Janzen-Wilde and colleagues, 1995).

The honest caveat matters, and it strengthens the case instead of weakening it: Reporting positive authorship evidence is not the same as proving that every message from every user is independently authored. Most of these are small studies or single cases, and several authors say so themselves. Authorship is best evaluated for a particular person, message, and set of conditions, which is exactly why one blanket rule from a professional body is a poor fit.

A 2026 systematic review of RPM and S2C, led by Ralf Schlosser with co-authors including Howard Shane, Katharine Beals, Russell Lang, and Bronwyn Hemsley, found no eligible studies. Those are four of the same names behind the ASHA convention sessions. The review set narrow criteria. A study had to evaluate RPM, S2C, or a close variant, and it had to use a controlled message-passing design that deliberately varied what the partner and the communicator knew. That rule leaves out the 1990s message-passing studies, which examined classic facilitated communication. It also leaves out studies that infer authorship from eye movements or other selection behavior, such as the 2020 Jaswal eye-tracking study. So the “empty review” does not mean no supportive studies exist. It means none fit the review’s definition, and that definition was written by the same people now teaching clinicians to doubt these methods.

Where I Stand on Communication Partner-Assisted Spelling

ASHA is positioning itself as the enemy of me and many of my friends. I have friends who use FC, RPM, and S2C, and it angers me that someone is calling vital communication harmful.

If apraxia “cannot explain why someone needs a communication partner”, then anyone with apraxia is automatically barred from communicating. That is a strange place for a speech and language body to land.

ASHA’s own vision statement says “Making effective communication, a human right, accessible and achievable for all.” A human right that only applies to people who communicate in ways the organization already approved is not a human right.

Over the course of the last 25 years, I have made friends with many people who use some form of spelling to communicate. Some of my friends are new, and some I have known for many years. I have observed my friends having conversations with me with different communication partners, and their words and thoughts did not change. I have watched some of my friends move from typing only with a communication partner to independent typing with one or both hands, and their words and thoughts did not change.

Can there be cases of someone’s communication being influenced? Of course. The same thing happens to speaking people. Have there been people harmed by flawed methods of spelling with a communication partner? I’m not denying it.

But what I am denying is the idea that these methods are uniformly and universally harmful. We should not be taking communication away from people based on isolated cases, any more than we should be taking children away from parents because some parents are abusive. Or, for example, restricting children from signing up for little league because some coaches have abused their players.

Don’t non-speaking Autistic people deserve the same consideration and options? Methods like facilitated communication (FC), rapid prompting method (RPM), and spelling to communicate (S2C) have literally saved lives, including the lives of friends I love. The actions ASHA is taking will doom many Autistic people to a life without communication and self-advocacy.

What to Watch

Sources

The Protective Power of Timely Withdrawal

When Autistic people withdraw during a conflict, too often we are treated as a problem.

People assume we step back because we’re not engaged in the conversation or motivated to work through the conflict. Pausing a conversation gets read as avoidance. Creating distance is taken as a refusal to work things through. The underlying expectations are clear: Care looks like staying present. Responsibility means continuing the interaction without a break until it is resolved.

When an Autistic person withdraws, that choice is rarely understood on its own terms. It is labeled: avoidance, stonewalling, punishment, manipulation. These labels do more than just describe behavior. They assign intent and motive, turning a person’s decision to take time and space into a moral judgment against them.

For many Autistic people, however, timely withdrawal serves a different purpose. It is a way of re-regulating a distressed nervous system before full dysregulation takes hold. Withdrawing from conflict helps preserve clarity, reduce harm, and make continued relationship possible. What is often framed as disengagement is, in practice, a means of staying safe enough to remain connected.

 

What “Timely Withdrawal” Means

I’m not talking about disappearing, abandoning relationships, or refusing accountability. I’m not arguing for disengagement as an endpoint, and I’m not defending avoiding difficult conversations. The focus here is narrower and more specific: how and when stepping back and taking time to collect oneself can prevent harm rather than create it.

Timely withdrawal means choosing to create temporary distance before nervous-system overwhelm takes hold. It can look like pausing a conversation, leaving a charged environment, or taking space long enough for regulation to return. Instead of pushing through when capacity is already strained, timely withdrawal allows the nervous system to settle so that thinking, language, and judgment can come back online.

Timing is the key distinction. Stepping away early, while some capacity remains, is very different from being forced to endure an interaction past one’s limits. When withdrawal happens proactively, it functions as a stabilizing pause. The longer withdrawal is delayed, and the more regulation has unraveled before taking a break, the more reactive that withdrawal becomes. When that happens, the break itself is much less effective at preserving stability and safety.

 The difference that makes withdrawal timely is not the act of pulling back, but the choice to step away sooner rather than too late.

 

The False Moral Binary

In most social settings in the country where I live (the United States), people seem to understand a simple rule about interpersonal conflict: staying with the conversation is treated as a virtue, while leaving is treated as a failure. Remaining engaged is associated with maturity, care, and responsibility. Stepping away, by contrast, is often read as immaturity, hostility, or a lack of commitment. This creates a familiar binary in which continued presence is assumed to be constructive and withdrawal is treated as suspect, regardless of what is actually happening for the people involved.

This binary rests on hidden assumptions about capacity. It assumes that everyone has equal access to nervous system regulation, verbal precision, and emotional bandwidth at all times. In reality, people differ widely in how they process stress, sensory input, and emotional intensity. For Neurodivergent people, the ability to remain present and articulate under pressure can fluctuate significantly. Treating “staying” and clear communication in the heat of the moment as things that should always be possible ignores these differences. It mistakes unequal capacity for unequal care.

For Autistic people caught inside this framework, conflict presents an impossible choice. Staying risks escalating dysregulation and loss of capacity. Leaving to prevent that escalation invites accusation and blame. One option is framed as a failure of self-control; the other as a failure of character. When both paths are punished, the problem is not individual behavior. The problem is the system that defines what counts as acceptable in the first place.

What Happens When Withdrawal Is Denied

For anyone, as stress increases, capacity narrows in predictable ways. For Autistic people, this effect is amplified. Most Autistic people reach high levels of stress with a lower threshold of input.

 Sensory input can become overwhelming, making it harder to filter sounds, sights, or internal sensations. Verbal precision may decline, with language becoming slower, less flexible, or more effortful to produce. In some cases, the nervous system interprets the situation as a serious threat, and defensive language emerges: angrier or more forceful than intended. 

Under this kind of pressure, attention constricts and response options narrow, making it difficult to track nuance or adapt in real time. These shifts are not matters of choice or attitude; they reflect how the nervous system functions under sustained load.

There is a common belief that sticking with the conversation will eventually lead to clarity or resolution. But once capacity has been exceeded, continued engagement rarely improves understanding or communication. More time and more pressure do not restore regulation. Instead, they tend to further tax already limited personal resources. In these conditions, persistence stops functioning as problem-solving and becomes additional strain on top of the original conflict.

When withdrawal is blocked or discouraged, escalation becomes more likely rather than less. Opportunities for early exit are replaced by forced endurance, increasing the chances of dysregulated responses that lead to negative attention and real consequences. Denying withdrawal can produce the very outcomes that are then judged and condemned.

Why Withdrawal Is So Often Misread

Many people are used to handling conflict through immediacy. There is an expectation that concerns should be addressed right away, out loud, and in the moment. Strong feelings are often met with direct confrontation, and staying in the conversation is taken as a sign of sincerity, care, and commitment.

Within this framework, withdrawal is easy to misread. A pause meant to reduce overload can look like silence. Taking distance to restore capacity can look like rejection or disengagement. When someone regulates by stepping back instead of pressing forward, that choice often doesn’t register as regulation at all. It registers as absence.

Most of the time, this misreading is not intentional. People interpret behavior using the norms they know. But intent doesn’t erase impact. When withdrawal is repeatedly interpreted as avoidance, punishment, or lack of care, real harm can occur, even when no one meant to cause it.

Withdrawal as Harm Reduction

Timely withdrawal can be understood as a form of harm reduction. It is a way of responding early to rising strain, before damage becomes difficult or impossible to undo. When a situation is becoming unstable, stepping back can limit how much harm occurs and how far it spreads. In moments where no option is entirely without cost, withdrawal can be the choice that reduces risk rather than escalating it.

The harm at stake is not abstract. When dysregulation escalates unchecked, people can lose jobs, relationships, reputations, and access to community. They can lose standing in workplaces or educational settings, be pushed out of housing or social networks, or find themselves excluded from spaces they once belonged to. In some contexts, the consequences can extend even further, including loss of freedom or serious threats to physical safety. These outcomes are not the result of poor character or bad intentions; they are the result of being pushed past capacity without a way to pause or exit.

Dysregulated responses such as meltdowns and shutdowns are not matters of choice or intent. They occur when regulatory capacity has been exceeded, not when someone “decides” to lose control. Acting to prevent that threshold from being crossed is not manipulation or coercion. It is a preventive step taken to preserve stability and safety in situations where the costs of escalation can be severe.

Care does not always look like continued engagement. Sometimes the most responsible action available is to step back before irreversible harm occurs. Care sometimes looks like distance.

Timely Withdrawal Preserves Relationship

When withdrawal is timely, it isn’t taken before it’s needed. But when withdrawal happens early enough, it can prevent harm that is hard (or impossible) to undo later. Taking space before capacity collapses lowers the chance of saying or doing things that permanently damage trust or safety. In that sense, withdrawal is not a rupture itself. It can be one of the ways a relationship is protected from true rupture.

Stepping back from a stressful experience is not the same as stepping away from a relationship, job, or course of education. Pausing to restore capacity does not mean care, commitment, or responsibility have disappeared. Treating temporary distance as abandonment collapses two very different things into one and misses what the pause is actually for.

Many ruptures that get blamed on withdrawal do not happen because someone left. They happen because someone could not leave. When leaving is denied, discouraged, or treated as morally wrong, pressure builds with nowhere to go. In those situations, damage often occurs not because distance was taken, but because it wasn’t allowed.

Supportive Agreements (Before Conflict)

Talking about withdrawal ahead of time often makes the difference between it being taken as harm or as care. When people have shared understanding about pauses and exits, taking space doesn’t come as a shock. Without that understanding, withdrawal gets interpreted in the most stressful moment, when assumptions tend to rush in and fill the gap.

A helpful understanding can be as simple as knowing that stepping away is allowed when capacity is strained. Discussing withdrawal before it happens (or during a calm time afterward) means having language that helps people tell the difference between taking necessary recovery space and abandoning a relationship. Understanding doesn’t dictate how long a pause should last or how things must be resolved when the pause has ended. It just makes it possible for distance to be seen as regulation, not rejection.

The timing of these conversations matters. They need to happen outside of active conflict, not in the middle of things unraveling. When expectations are named ahead of time, pauses don’t have to be defended or negotiated under pressure. That matters, especially when an Autistic person may not have the words or calm required to explain or even excuse themselves. The withdrawal can be taken as needed, and (hopefully) understood in its true spirit, not erroneously interpreted and judged.

A Principle, Not a Preference

For many Autistic people, the ability to withdraw is not a matter of comfort or personal style. It is a necessary condition for maintaining regulation, safety, and the ability to participate at all. Treating withdrawal as optional misunderstands its role and places demands on capacity that cannot be reliably met.

What is at stake is not convenience, but the basic conditions that make interaction possible. Safety depends on the ability to prevent overwhelm. Dignity depends on having one’s limits recognized. Autonomy is only preserved when one’s needs are honored. Continuity depends on reducing harm that cannot easily be repaired. When withdrawal is respected, these conditions are far more likely to hold.

Timely withdrawal is not a failure to care.

It is often the action that makes care possible at all.

© 2026 Unstrange Mind

Theme by Anders Noren — Up ↑